Stefanie Milam

Visiting from the USA and wanted a good steak dinner. Small and quaint place with friendly staff. I ordered a glass of Malbec and the filet (rare) with Diane sauce. The steak was prepared perfect on the grill, the sauce was very good, and the baked potato nice and soft with a crispy skin. I'm very impressed.

Abbie Chadwick-Wood

Food was amazing! Service took a while, but the food was worth the wait! Staff are extremely caring and take the time to talk to their customers. Hand on heart will go again!

Susie Maxwell

Have to say that was an incredible meal with fantastic service. All the food was good but the steaks were exceptional. Very grateful to the staff for looking after us so well. 🙏

Matthew Turner

Walking in you would be forgiven for thinking you've walked back in time to a 90's Italian restaurant, but don't let the dated decor fool you. The staff were funny and helpful, very informative of the menu choices. The portion was very generous, the starter was like a main by itself. I had the mixed grill, the steak was soft and flavoursome, the lamb fell off the bone and cooked to perfection. Highly recommended.

Wallace Murphy

Superb food. Had the haggis for starter was very tasty. Staff were excellent couldn't recommend enough. Steak was out of this world, I had the ribeye one of the best I've had 🤗

Jules G

Very smart well laid out restaurant. I love steaks and burgers. If I had to eat steak every meal for the rest of my life I would not be devastated. Whilst I began to think the wait for the food was slightly long I understood why when it arrived. The nicest steak I've ever had. I'm 37 and I love steaks to put that in perspective. Outside on the window it says 'owned by butchers' and boy does this show. My chargrilled rump tasted unlike anything I've had before.... The chargrilled taste was superb. This was along with extremely nice on-the-vine tomatoes and curly fries. I savoured my steak from start to finish and have never wanted to pass on my appreciation to the chef because of their steak before. (unless the chef is the Mrs and you pretty much have to)

A real steakhouse done well with emphasis on great cuts of meat brilliantly cooked.

Aaron Barker

If I could give this place 100 stars I would by far the best burger to pass my mouth, I had the black and blue burger 🍔 absolutely beautiful. My partner had the 10oz sirloin steak medium rare and it was a beautiful piece of meat, staff was lovely highly recommended.

Catherine Crichton

I was at McKirdy's with 2 friends last evening. We had haggis, mini sausages and ribs for starters and all had steaks for mains. They were all excellent. The staff were all very friendly. All round a great restaurant.

Andrea Piekut

Meat was delicious and perfectly done, sides on the point and sauces add even more taste to the whole.
All in all, 1st-class experience in a very informal yet fully professional place.
I'll definitely be back 😊

Cameron Christensen

Amazing food and dinning experience! Small place that smells delicious and tastes the same! We got the garlic mushrooms for an appetizer! The sauce was a must have. And I ordered the ribeye seared in a pan and it tasted wonderfully!

Emily Pick

From start to finish this place was amazing! The staff were brilliant and the food was even better! 100% recommend this place for food, and will be returning x

Chris Osbo

Perfectly cooked steaks. At our table we had medium rare, medium and well done steaks all where to a T. Starters and sides where equally delicious. As was sticky toffee desert. Waitress Alison was very polite and informative. A great meal all at our table thoroughly enjoyed.

Mark Coureau

This place was recommended to me by a colleague and wow, what a great meal! The service was exceptional and the food delightful. Probably the best steak I've ever had. Its not a massive restaurant so booking is a must. We will definitely be back when we visit Edinburgh again.

Kevin Olding

Exceptionally good steak, cooked to perfection. Would highly recommend the Clansman sauce to accompany too. Pudding was also very nice but the steak was the main event for sure!

Mikey Jones

Fantastic T-Bone, visited with my wife and 11 month old last night. Staff were very friendly and made us feel welcome. Great night had by us the best steak in Edinburgh so far